Everything is Better with Ice Cream

The summer Leo Mendoza fell in love started with a dripping waffle cone and an overconfident smile.

He hadn’t meant to go to Cold Front Creamery that night. He was supposed to be on a date — a real one, with someone named Patrick or Preston or one of those names that sounded like a sailboat trust fund. But the guy canceled, and Leo decided ice cream was better company anyway.

Which is when he met Theo Romano.

Theo was the guy behind the counter, all broad shoulders and forearms that should’ve come with a warning label. He was also making eye contact like he was trying to break a world record for it.

“You look like a Rocky Road man,” Theo said, leaning on the counter like a rom-com villain who’d accidentally been cast as the love interest.

Leo, who had been raised on Catholic guilt and queer panic, stammered, “I, uh, prefer Mint Chip?”

“Even better,” Theo said, grinning. “It’s the thinking man’s flavor.”

And that was it. Hook, line, and sinker.

---

Sprinkles and Secrets

They started dating in the quiet spaces — after closing, during inventory, in the cramped back office that smelled like vanilla extract and stress. It wasn’t a secret because they were ashamed. It was just… theirs.

But even in secret, they were building something bigger than themselves. Cold Front became known not just for ice cream but for what it stood for.

They started hosting Pride nights. Donated to LGBTQIA+ shelters. Made a flavor called “Love Is Love Lemon” that was too sour for most people but sold out every time anyway.

The shop felt like the kind of place where you could come in broken and leave with two scoops of something that made the world suck less.

---

The Big Contract

Three years in, The Giant Cone Company showed up like a shark in an expensive suit.

They wanted Cold Front. The brand, the vibe, the sprinkles — all of it.

The offer: national expansion, corporate money, endless resources.

The catch: corporate money, endless resources.

Theo and Leo fought for weeks over the decision. Then they fought with the company lawyers for months after that.

The final contract read like a love letter to ethics: no artificial flavors, no corporate meddling with Pride events, no erasure of what made Cold Front queer and loud and theirs.

They set up a community board to protect the soul of the business. Employees got shares. Rainbow sprinkles became a non-negotiable clause.

They signed, triumphant. For a while, it worked.

---

Success, Melting

Expansion was wild. New shops in new cities. Influencers posting TikToks in front of neon Cold Front signs. A pop-up in Paris that sold out daily.

Theo loved it — the chaos, the growth, the idea that their tiny dream had taken over the world.

Leo loved it too… until he didn’t.

Success came with pressure: quarterly reports, franchise politics, supply chain nightmares. Somewhere along the line, the ice cream stopped feeling like rebellion and started feeling like paperwork.

---

The Break

The fight that ended it started over waffle cones.

Technically, it was about whether to source them from a cheaper supplier. But really, it was about everything else: Leo wanting to protect the heart of the shop, Theo wanting to keep up with expansion.

“You can’t sell love on a quarterly report,” Leo snapped, hands shaking.

“And you can’t run a business on nostalgia,” Theo shot back.

The next day, Leo was gone.

---

Aftermath

Theo stayed.

He kept the empire running. He made speeches at Pride parades and scholarships in Leo’s name. He always told the press:

“This was Leo’s dream, too. Don’t forget that.”

And people didn’t.

Leo opened a small shop back home, just one little creamery with hand-painted signs and too many plants in the windows. It wasn’t famous. It wasn’t an empire.

But every June, he’d mail Theo a card with nothing inside but a single rainbow sprinkle taped to the paper.

Because some things don’t melt.